Professionals better at facial recognition than even computers
Example of the types of image matching trials presented to examiners in the
experiments. Each test consisted of a pair of images and participants had to
decide if images were of the same person or of different people. The images
in the upright column measure ability to identify face images. The images
in the inverted column were included to assess whether examiners used
different strategies to identify faces. The images in the person identification
require examiners to use the face and body for recognition. Image pairs
in each column in this example are of different people.
Forensic examiners pass the face matching test
The first study to test the skills of FBI agents and other law enforcers who have been trained in facial recognition has provided a reassuring result -- they perform better than the average person or even computers on this difficult task.
The research also suggests that trained facial forensic examiners identify faces in a different way to the small number of people who are naturally very good at face matching -- the so-called super-recognisers.
"Super-recognisers tested in previous studies appear to rely on automatic, holistic processes when they compare facial images, but forensic examiners use analytical methods," says research leader UNSW Australia psychologist Dr David White.
|Our Biometric Future:|
Facial Recognition Technology
Culture of Surveillance
by Kelly Gates
Order new or used from
"These identifications affect the course and outcome of criminal investigations and convictions. But despite calls for research on any human error in forensic proceedings, the performance of the experts carrying out the face matching had not previously been examined," says Dr White.
"The examiners' superiority was greatest when they had a longer time to study the images, and they were also more accurate than others at matching faces when the faces were shown upside down. This is consistent with them tuning into the finer details in an image, rather than relying on the whole face."
For the study, the researchers tested an international group of 27 facial forensic examiners with many years of experience who were attending a meeting of the Facial identification Scientific Work Group. The group's member agencies include the FBI, and police and customs and border protection services in the US, Australia and other countries.
The trained experts were given three tests where they had to decide if pairs of images were of the same person. Their performance was compared to that of a control group of non-experts who were attending the same meeting, as well as a group of untrained students.
The pairs of images used were selected to be particularly challenging, reflected in the fact that computer algorithms were 100 per cent wrong on one of the tests. For some of the tests participants were given 2 seconds, or 30 seconds, to decide.
"Overall, our study is good news. It provides the first evidence that these professional examiners are experts at their work. They were consistently more accurate on all tasks than the controls and the students," says Dr White.
"However, it is important to note that although the tests were challenging, the images were relatively good quality. Faces were captured on high-resolution cameras, in favorable lighting conditions and subjects were looking straight at the camera.
"This is often not the case when images are extracted from surveillance footage," says Dr White.
- 1/3 of Hate Crimes Committed by Friends, Care-givers & Family
- Brain Activity Can Predict if You Might Commit a Crime
- Guilt vs. Shame Predict Criminal Re-offense
- How Visiting High Crime Neighborhood Effects People
- Inside the Minds of Murderers
- It's Getting Harder to Hide Murder
- Killing for Money: Does Crime Pay?
- People Can 'Beat' Guilt Detection Tests
- Plotting Crime Through the Eyes of Burglars
- Predicting who will murder his wife or family
- Questioning Longstanding Forensic Identification
- Strict Societies = Violent Drinking Cultures
- The True Causes of Crime
- What Can Investigators Really Tell From Gunshot Residue?
- Where have all the burglars gone?