Roman Gladiators were vegetarians? Yes, and they drank ash tonics as well.
Roman Gladiators ate a mostly vegetarian diet and drank a tonic of ashes after training? That goes against every image I've ever held dear. When you picture a gladiator eating, don't you picture him with a goblet of mead in one hand and a joint of meat in the other, tearing off big chunks of meat like a carnivore on the Serengeti? I do.
The conclusions of this research destroys this view. The thought of big, hulking brutes nibbling from a pile of asparagus and cauliflower is dissonant in the extreme, especially veggies without ranch dressing. Where's the blood and grease dripping off their chins? Where's the gnawed bone thrown into the corners for slaves or starving lions to finish off? Next, they'll tell me gladiators didn't feast with one arm wrapped around a buxom serving wench in a revealing toga. I'm sorry, but this does not compute.
Ah, but it's science, and the basic rule of science is that whether you like a result or not, it's true. Sigh. There go more cherished images of my childhood.
Here's the report:
Historic sources report that gladiators had their own diet comprised of beans and grains. In fact, contemporary reports referred to them as "hordearii" ("barley eaters").
Using spectroscopy, stable isotope ratios (carbon, nitrogen and sulphur) were investigated in the collagen of the bones, along with the ratio of strontium to calcium in the bone mineral.
The result shows that gladiators mostly ate a vegetarian diet. There is virtually no difference in terms of nutrition from the local "normal population." Meals consisted primarily of grain and meat-free meals. The word "barley eater" relates in this case to the fact that gladiators were probably given grain of an inferior quality.
Build-up drink following physical exertion
The difference between gladiators and the normal population is highly significant in terms of the amount of strontium measured in their bones. This leads to the conclusion that the gladiators had a higher intake of minerals from a strontium-rich source of calcium. The ash drink quoted in literature probably really did exist. "Plant ashes were evidently consumed to fortify the body after physical exertion and to promote better bone healing," explains study leader Fabian Kanz from the Department of Forensic Medicine at the MedUni Vienna. "Things were similar then to what we do today -- we take magnesium and calcium (in the form of effervescent tablets, for example) following physical exertion." Calcium is essential for bone building and usually occurs primarily in milk products.
A further research project is looking at the migration of gladiators, who often came from different parts of the Roman Empire to Ephesos. The researchers are hoping that comparison of the bone data from gladiators with that of the local fauna will yield a number of differences.
Related stories:
A Step Toward Understanding Arabic Language and Culture
Ayla and Jondular had blue eyes, but were black
Greek Bronze Age ended 100 years earlier than thought
How Our Stone Age Ancestors Lived & Hid
The Killing Advantage of Stone Tipped Spears
Oldest fortified settlement ever found in North America
The Quest for Fire, Revisited
Two thousand years of intellectual freedom mapped
The Unknown Volcanic Eruption of 1808 & Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
Who Died in 1930's Blazing Car Murder?
The conclusions of this research destroys this view. The thought of big, hulking brutes nibbling from a pile of asparagus and cauliflower is dissonant in the extreme, especially veggies without ranch dressing. Where's the blood and grease dripping off their chins? Where's the gnawed bone thrown into the corners for slaves or starving lions to finish off? Next, they'll tell me gladiators didn't feast with one arm wrapped around a buxom serving wench in a revealing toga. I'm sorry, but this does not compute.
Ah, but it's science, and the basic rule of science is that whether you like a result or not, it's true. Sigh. There go more cherished images of my childhood.
Here's the report:
Anthropology unlocks clues about
Roman gladiators' eating habits.
Historic sources report that gladiators had their own diet comprised of beans and grains. In fact, contemporary reports referred to them as "hordearii" ("barley eaters").
In a study by the Department of Forensic Medicine at the MedUni Vienna in cooperation with the Department of Anthropology at the Institute of Forensic Medicine at the University of Bern, bones were examined from a gladiator cemetery uncovered in 1993 which dates back to the 2nd or 3rd century BC in the then Roman city of Ephesos (now in modern-day Turkey). At the time, Ephesos was the capital of the Roman province of Asia and had over 200,000 inhabitants.
Using spectroscopy, stable isotope ratios (carbon, nitrogen and sulphur) were investigated in the collagen of the bones, along with the ratio of strontium to calcium in the bone mineral.
The result shows that gladiators mostly ate a vegetarian diet. There is virtually no difference in terms of nutrition from the local "normal population." Meals consisted primarily of grain and meat-free meals. The word "barley eater" relates in this case to the fact that gladiators were probably given grain of an inferior quality.
Build-up drink following physical exertion
The difference between gladiators and the normal population is highly significant in terms of the amount of strontium measured in their bones. This leads to the conclusion that the gladiators had a higher intake of minerals from a strontium-rich source of calcium. The ash drink quoted in literature probably really did exist. "Plant ashes were evidently consumed to fortify the body after physical exertion and to promote better bone healing," explains study leader Fabian Kanz from the Department of Forensic Medicine at the MedUni Vienna. "Things were similar then to what we do today -- we take magnesium and calcium (in the form of effervescent tablets, for example) following physical exertion." Calcium is essential for bone building and usually occurs primarily in milk products.
A further research project is looking at the migration of gladiators, who often came from different parts of the Roman Empire to Ephesos. The researchers are hoping that comparison of the bone data from gladiators with that of the local fauna will yield a number of differences.
Related stories:
* * * * *
Story Source: Materials provided by Medical University of Vienna. Journandra Lösch, Negahnaz Moghaddam, Karl Grossschmidt, Daniele U. Risser, Fabian Kanz. Stable Isotope and Trace Element Studies on Gladiators and Contemporary Romans from Ephesus (Turkey, 2nd and 3rd Ct. AD) - Implications for Differences in Diet. PLoS One, October 15, 2014
Comments
Post a Comment